Keurig K-Supreme vs K-Supreme Plus: 7 Key Differences
Naila Syifa
Updated April 2025
When it comes to single-serve coffee makers, Keurig stands as one of the most recognized brands in the market. Their K-Supreme and K-Supreme Plus models, retailing at USD 169.99 and USD 219.99 respectively, represent their more advanced offerings.
We have compared the two coffee makers and noted the seven most important differences between them. What are they? Let's find out!
Key Takeaways
The K-Supreme Plus offers enhanced customization with additional temperature, strength, and size settings, plus programmable favorites for three users and a larger water reservoir in a stainless steel finish. Meanwhile, the K-Supreme provides dual-position water reservoir flexibility and more color options at a lower price point.
Keurig K-Supreme
Single-Serve Coffee Maker
✓ 4 Cup Sizes
✓ 66 oz. Dual-Positon Reservoir
✓ Strong Brew & Over Ice
✓ MultiStream Technology
Keurig K-Supreme Plus
Premium Single-Serve Coffee Maker
✓ 5 Cup Sizes
✓ 78 oz. Removable Reservoir
✓ Strength & Temperature Control
✓ Programmable Favorites
Similarities
Keurig K-Supreme
Before diving into the differences, let's take a moment to review a few key similarities between the Keurig K-Supreme and K-Supreme Plus.
First of all, both are single-serve coffee makers with Keurig's MultiStream technology. This technology uses 5 needles instead of one to saturate the coffee grounds more evenly for fuller flavor extraction. In simple terms, it makes coffee more flavorful.
Both machines can serve not only hot coffee but also iced beverages. Simply prepare ice in a tumbler, press the "Over Ice" button, and enjoy a refreshing cold coffee, tea, cocoa, and others without the diluted taste.
Lastly, both the K-Supreme and K-Supreme Plus can fit a travel mug, thanks to their removable drip trays.
Differences
#1 Water Reservoir
Keurig K-Supreme
The K-Supreme Plus houses a larger water reservoir, capable of holding 78 ounces (2,31 liters) of water compared to the K-Supreme's 66-ounce (1,95 liters) capacity.
A larger water tank means the more space it takes up on your counter, but also the more cups of coffee you can brew before needing to refill.
While both reservoirs are removable for easy refilling, only the standard K-Supreme's reservoir supports dual position. You can place it either on the side or behind the machine to better fit your counter space, making it flexible for different kitchen layouts.
The reservoir on the K-Supreme Plus, meanwhile, must remain in its fixed position at the side of the machine.
#2 Strong Brew Settings
Keurig K-Supreme Plus
Both the K-Supreme and K-Supreme Plus offer a strong brew feature. It allows you to enjoy a more intense, bold cup of coffee by slowing down the brewing process for deeper extraction.
The difference is that the Plus model offers three strength settings compared to the standard model's single strong brew option. That means, you have more control over the intensity of your coffee with the Plus.
#3 Temperature Settings
Keurig K-Supreme
Keurig K-Supreme Plus offers three different water temperature settings. You can adjust how hot your coffee brews based on your preference.
Simply press the "TEMP" button to cycle through the three temperature options: low, medium, and high.
Meanwhile, the standard K-Supreme lacks temperature control altogether. So, you'll have to accept the default brewing temperature.
#4 Brew Size Settings
Keurig K-Supreme Plus
Brew size is how much coffee you want to make in a single serving. A larger brew size uses more water, resulting in a larger but less concentrated cup of coffee. On the contrary, a smaller brew size creates a more concentrated, stronger-tasting cup.
The Keurig K-Supreme offers 4 brew sizes, while the K-Supreme Plus offers 5 brew sizes.
Keurig K-Supreme: 6, 8, 10, 12 ounces
Keurig K-Supreme Plus: 4, 6, 8, 10, 12 ounces
As we can see, the Plus model has an edge with a 4-ounce option, making it particularly appealing for those who prefer a smaller, more concentrated cup.
If you're not that type of coffee drinker, the standard K-Supreme's size options will likely be sufficient.
#5 User Preference Settings
Keurig K-Supreme Plus
Now that we have arrived at this point, we can agree that the Keurig K-Supreme Plus offers quite a degree of customization. But with so many settings to select each time, brewing your perfect cup could become tedious.
This is where the programmable favorites feature comes in handy, allowing us to set user preference settings for up to 3 users.
To save brew settings, simply select the desired brew size, brew strength, and temperature. Then press and hold one of the three user profile buttons on the control interface.
Next time you want to brew your perfect cup, just press your profile button and the machine will automatically use your saved settings.
Homes with multiple coffee drinkers will appreciate this feature, but one individual can also benefit if they enjoy different types of coffee at various times of the day.
#6 Control Interface
Keurig K-Supreme vs K-Supreme Plus
Keurig K-Supreme and K-Supreme Plus have their control interface on top of the machine, which is easy to access and operate.
The Plus model offers more customization settings, so it is only natural that it has a more sophisticated control panel.
Not only does it have more buttons, but the K-Supreme Plus also adds a digital display, which is absent on the standard K-Supreme model. Unfortunately, the display only shows settings like brew strength and temperature, not touch controls or a full menu system.
#7 Color & Finish
Keurig K-Supreme Plus
The Keurig K-Supreme offers 3 color variants: Black, Gray, and White. If you prefer a certain color to match your kitchen decor, you'll have more options with the standard model.
The K-Supreme Plus only comes in the Silver variant, but it has a premium feel because of the stainless steel metal wrap.
Regardless of which model you choose, both coffee makers feature a modern appearance that would complement most kitchen aesthetics.
Keurig K-Supreme vs K-Supreme Plus
Final Thoughts
Keurig K-Supreme
When deciding between the Keurig K-Supreme and K-Supreme Plus, your choice ultimately depends on how much customization you want in your coffee experience.
The standard K-Supreme delivers excellent coffee with MultiStream technology at a more affordable price point, while offering flexibility in placement and color options.
The K-Supreme Plus justifies its higher price tag with additional brew settings, temperature control, programmable favorites, and a larger water reservoir—all wrapped in a premium stainless steel finish.
If you'd like to read more about Coffee Makers, check out our other relevant guides here:
Keurig K-Mini vs K-Express
Keurig K-Express vs K-Slim
Author
Naila Syifa
Naila has spent over 1,800 hours researching, exploring, and writing about the latest trends in technology, consumer electronics, and smart home gadgets.
Don't miss out on tech
Subscribe to our newsletter to stay up to date on the latest tech trends and guides on the best gadgets around.
